Photo: © Illustrated.

The Lobster Republic

How a Fishing Cooperative Divided the Ocean Floor Into Territories and Built a Celebrated Lobster Fishery

115
Numbered Fishing Territories (Campos), Held by 41 Owners
Top lobster producer in Quintana Roo for 30+ years
Part of a six-cooperative lobster fishery that earned MSC certification in 2012
Rules backed by community self-policing and internal penalties

THE TERRITORY SYSTEM

🏖️
115 Campos
Individual fishing territories
🏠
Casitas Cubanas
Cuban-inspired lobster shelters
🤿
Free-diving Harvest
Selective, sustainable capture
👨‍👩‍👧‍👦
Inheritance Only
Membership limited to children

56 Years of Innovation: From Coconuts to Certification

1960s
Cuban traders introduce lobster shelter technique ("casitas Cubanas") to isolated village
1968
Fishermen form Vigía Chico Cooperative after splitting from Cozumel cooperative
1980s
Fishery grows under the cooperative's exclusive federal concession
1986
Sian Ka'an Biosphere Reserve created - cooperative adapts practices for conservation compatibility
1988
Hurricane Gilbert creates financial crisis; membership restricted to children of current members
2012
MSC certification awarded to the Sian Ka'an and Banco Chinchorro lobster fishery, which covers six cooperatives
Present
Roughly 70 members (published estimates vary) maintain a widely studied model for community fisheries

The Choice That Changed Everything

After Mexico ended open access to fishing in 1947, cooperatives held exclusive concessions for valuable species such as spiny lobster. Within its concession, the Punta Allen cooperative made a distinctive choice: divide the ocean floor into numbered territories, each held by an individual member.

The Cuban Connection
Cuban traders sailing to the isolated village brought more than goods - they shared the secret of "casitas Cubanas," artificial lobster shelters that concentrate spiny lobsters in predictable locations. Don Antonio Perreira, the cooperative's founder, first built these shelters from local Chit Palm. This technique would become the foundation of their territorial system.

The innovation was brilliant: instead of competing fishermen racing to catch lobsters wherever they could find them, each owner holds exclusive rights to one or more "campos" - numbered pieces of ocean floor. There are 115 campos, held by 41 owners. They deployed artificial shelters in their territories and harvested lobsters by free-diving with handheld nets, allowing egg-bearing females and juveniles to be released unharmed.

1988: The Resilience Test
Hurricane Gilbert devastated the community and destroyed plans for a lobster processing plant, leaving the cooperative in financial crisis. Many members left rather than help pay the collective debt. Those who remained made a crucial decision: new memberships would only be extended to children of current members, creating sustainable population limits that persist today.
1960s: Coconut farming economy and an isolated fishing village
2024: Top lobster producer in Quintana Roo, part of an MSC-certified fishery, widely studied community fisheries model

Territorial System Success

115
Individual Territories
850
Km² Managed
56
Years Operating
41
Owners of the 115 Campos
30+
Years Top Producer
2012
Lobster Fishery MSC Certified
1986
Sian Ka'an Reserve Created
2007
Equator Prize

Global Recognition

"The top producer of spiny lobster in the state of Quintana Roo for over 30 years, this cooperative has been claimed as an example of a sustainable artisanal fishery. By dividing up the ocean floor and issuing corresponding fishing rights, this community has avoided the 'tragedy of the commons' that plagues many other fishing communities."
- Méndez-Medina et al., Maritime Studies, 2015

The Punta Allen model has become a global case study for Territorial Use Rights in Fisheries (TURF). Their system suggests that when fishermen have secure, exclusive access to marine resources, they have strong reasons to look after them, although studies find no tight link to measured ecological outcomes. The cooperative received the Equator Prize in 2007.

When fishermen hold secure rights to the ocean floor,
they fish like farmers,
not like hunters.

Within their cooperative's concession, the fishermen of Punta Allen made a distinctive choice: divide the ocean floor into 115 numbered territories. Each campo is held by an individual owner, 41 in all, giving them exclusive fishing rights and turning competitors into proprietors.

The results are notable: 56 years of continuous operation, 30+ years as Quintana Roo's top lobster producer, and a place in a lobster fishery that earned MSC certification in 2012. The cooperative enforces its own rules with internal penalties, and secure rights give members a reason to look after their territories.

Their innovation began with Cuban traders who taught them to build artificial lobster shelters. Instead of scattering these "casitas" randomly, Punta Allen fishermen deployed them strategically within their individual territories, creating underwater ranches where lobsters could be sustainably harvested by free-diving with handheld nets.

When Hurricane Gilbert struck in 1988 and financial crisis threatened the cooperative, those who remained made another crucial decision: membership would be inherited, not sold. Only children of current members could join, keeping membership limited. This rule remains in effect today.

The tragedy of the commons
becomes the triumph of ownership.
When the sea belongs to fishermen,
fishermen belong to the sea.