The Lobster Republic
How a Fishing Cooperative Divided the Ocean Floor Into Territories and Built a Celebrated Lobster Fishery
THE TERRITORY SYSTEM
56 Years of Innovation: From Coconuts to Certification
The Choice That Changed Everything
After Mexico ended open access to fishing in 1947, cooperatives held exclusive concessions for valuable species such as spiny lobster. Within its concession, the Punta Allen cooperative made a distinctive choice: divide the ocean floor into numbered territories, each held by an individual member.
The innovation was brilliant: instead of competing fishermen racing to catch lobsters wherever they could find them, each owner holds exclusive rights to one or more "campos" - numbered pieces of ocean floor. There are 115 campos, held by 41 owners. They deployed artificial shelters in their territories and harvested lobsters by free-diving with handheld nets, allowing egg-bearing females and juveniles to be released unharmed.
Territorial System Success
Global Recognition
The Punta Allen model has become a global case study for Territorial Use Rights in Fisheries (TURF). Their system suggests that when fishermen have secure, exclusive access to marine resources, they have strong reasons to look after them, although studies find no tight link to measured ecological outcomes. The cooperative received the Equator Prize in 2007.
Within their cooperative's concession, the fishermen of Punta Allen made a distinctive choice: divide the ocean floor into 115 numbered territories. Each campo is held by an individual owner, 41 in all, giving them exclusive fishing rights and turning competitors into proprietors.
The results are notable: 56 years of continuous operation, 30+ years as Quintana Roo's top lobster producer, and a place in a lobster fishery that earned MSC certification in 2012. The cooperative enforces its own rules with internal penalties, and secure rights give members a reason to look after their territories.
Their innovation began with Cuban traders who taught them to build artificial lobster shelters. Instead of scattering these "casitas" randomly, Punta Allen fishermen deployed them strategically within their individual territories, creating underwater ranches where lobsters could be sustainably harvested by free-diving with handheld nets.
When Hurricane Gilbert struck in 1988 and financial crisis threatened the cooperative, those who remained made another crucial decision: membership would be inherited, not sold. Only children of current members could join, keeping membership limited. This rule remains in effect today.